Frank Zane vs. Markus Ruhl

zane-ruhl

Frank Zane (classic bodybuilder) next to Markus Ruhl (current).

TWO SIMPLE QUESTIONS:

  1. Which look do you prefer if any?
  2. Is there such a thing as too big?

Submit your comments in the box below.

Marc David
“The NoBull Muscle Guy”
www.nobullbodybuilding.com

P.S. - I don’t have the information on who created this photo. But I’d be more than happy to give credit where credit is due.  I just can’t find a source.  If there is one, I’ll update this post to reflect that fact.

Categories: Random, Rants

  • Trey

    I prefer classic bodybuilders. Frank Zane and Arnold are my favorite bodies.

  • Kevin

    Zane – it is classic, achievable, attractive, and you can find clothes that fit. The attraction of a physique like Markus' is like the attraction of a car wreck.

  • tomtrav

    I prefer the classic look which has a much more helathier appearance than markus Ruhl's. I think the definition and proprtions are great but the classic look has the appearance of a greek statue carved out of marble. I also think the current look puts a lot of people off bodybuilding.

  • katherinehess

    As a 50-year-old woman, I'm certainly not commenting on which I would rather be – I'll never come close to even the “classic.” And for my preference, I'm not sure that even Frank Zane isn't too big. I will admit to being completely biased against visible veins. And I suspect that there's more to the “perfect” body than having big biceps/pecs/etc. Could be wrong, but shouldn't the optimum include a balance of flexibility, stamina, speed, and maybe other aspects?

    or maybe I'm confusing “health” with bodybuilding….

  • http://www.nobullbodybuilding.com Marc David

    Bodybuilding in many regards, is not healthy. But YOUR perspective on this is much appreciated. I desperately hoped a female would post their personal point of view on this one. There's no right answer here just opinions which I'm gobbling up like a kid in a Powell's Candy store.

  • Jay

    Classic is definately preferable, modern drug enhanced bodybuilding is a truely gross caricature and in no way shows how beautiful and healthy the human form can be

  • massmuscletips

    Hi,
    I prefer the classic bodybuilder.
    Frank Zane is perfect.
    I like the bodybuilding old school.

    Fred

  • http://www.dontbeapicklebump.com/ Paula

    I like the classic look much better. The “Modern” body builder just looks gross and unreal.

  • http://on-a-limb.com/ On a limb with Claudia

    Frank Zane is one of my original childhood crushes. He's just very yummy!

  • lessonsinhealth

    I prefer the Frank Zane look! Although, the other guy certainly looks like a Superhero!
    Marco-Lessons in Health

  • http://themiddlemanager.wordpress.com/2009/09/20/classic-vs-modern/ Classic Vs. Modern « The Middle Manager

    [...] Check it out here: Frank Zane vs. Markus Ruhl [...]

  • billyjacktnt

    Frank Zane. Before him, Steve Reeves. It's been downhill since then!!! The Classic look will never go out of style.

  • billyjacktnt

    Franz Zane hands down. Before him, Steve Reeves. The Classic look will never go out of style.

  • http://how-togain-weight.blogspot.com/ Weight Gainer

    its funny how people believe that classic body builders were only good. Even today we can find many good body builders, but since they are not the first ones to enter this field they are getting due respect which is sad. Arnold was defintely good but we should also promote new kids on the block to make it big and nice in the body building arena

  • kimmorrissey

    I met Frank, and spoke to him often back in 1974, when I trained at the first Gold's gym. He was also a judge at my win in the Mr.Eastern USA in 76.As we have a similar body type, this is what Frank shared with me.He said, Ï've won with steroids and without. In competion, no one is coming on stage to measure your arm. You might be a little heavier and certainly stronger, but a great defined physique is the goal.”After 40 years of being in and around the bodybuilding world, I beleive the exagerated physiques of the drug guys today appeal only to other drug guys and impressiionable 16 year old boys looking for super heros.These guys won't be buffed and enjoying the bodybuilding lifestyle at 68 years old, like Zane, Draper, and certainly the late, great Vince Goironda, who was instamental on both Zane and Draper. Zane was a key holder at Vinces gym in N.Hollywood.I trained there myself in the mid 80's.The bodybuiding lifestyle is just that.A lifestyle that promotes good health, strength, dissapline, and mental growth.The drugged out bodies of the pros today will not live to be the great men of tomorrow, and will enevidably find prison food not to their benefit or good to their palate or physiique! See my site at (themidlifehandbook.com).I am the author and conduct seminars with references from the Rath Foundation, Mayo Clinic, Ron Kosloff, Vince Gironda, Dave Draper, and others.I appreciate the fine work of the WNBF and Lift For Life, and all the guys like you that promote natural bodybuilding.We are saving the sport from sure destruction and giving it a healthy, respectable future! keep the pump!, Mr.Kim Morrissey

  • Patricia

    My preference definitely goes to Frank Zane. Current bodybuilders look simply bizarre. If I ever saw somebody like Ruhl on the street, I'd probably stare, and not in admiration.

  • dmurf

    Frank could only compete as a top natural today a stunning symetrical look although he used steroids i would like to think with modern supplements and a good understanding of diet and training this could be acheived with his ecto meso genes he truly is one of the greatest and proof that size is not as important as condition , he is simply the greatest

  • Mike

    I would rather have the body of Markus Ruhl. Frank is WAY too small and he has chicken legs. Classical bodybuilders are OK, but are way too underdeveloped. Even Arnold had chicken legs. I prefer Jay Cutler, Ruhl, and Ronnie Coleman. Modern bodybuilders are way Better.

  • Mike

    I would rather have the body of Markus Ruhl. Frank is WAY too small and he has chicken legs. Classical bodybuilders are OK, but are way too underdeveloped. Even Arnold had chicken legs. I prefer Jay Cutler, Ruhl, and Ronnie Coleman. Modern bodybuilders are way Better.

  • Moira

    Much prefer Zane. Speaking from a female perspective. I like muscle and I like a lot of it. But today's bodybuilders are in danger of looking like carictures of what a man should be. They look bubbly. Like bubbles gone wild. No offense.

  • AKA Trex

    I prefer Zane’s Look.

    Markus Ruhl has Won how many O’s?

  • guest

    Zane is in complete symmetry, the other guy is a steroid freak.

    I worked as a camera operator once at a body building competition that Ruhl was the winner of. That was a horrible experience. The smell backstage was staggering, a nauseating mix of steroid laced sweat, testosterone, sudden tanning and oil sprays, and the gas produced by these freaks who had eliminated the water in their bodies with diuretics and couldn’t stop farting.

    They all acted weird, too. Another side effect of massive steroid use, and the fact that they are a bunch of body dysmorphic, self loathing overcompensating losers.

    Sorry to put such a fine point on the thing. That being said, it’s time I went back to the gym and hit the weight pile.

  • Radaral

    The guy on the left I’m sure did and still does get laid alot more than the guy on the right. although it’s pretty amazing how big humans can get. though he’ll probably have really bad heart and liver problems by the time he’s 40.

  • Teerex

    There should be a competition; “how big CAN you go”, or is this modern bodybuilding just that, only mass matters? I think it’s interesting to see, what are the limits of human body, even that it has nothing to do with the healthy sport, but these people know what they are dealing with, and therefore it’s their decision.

  • Teerex

    There should be a competition; “how big CAN you go”, or is this modern bodybuilding just that, only mass matters? I think it’s interesting to see, what are the limits of human body, even that it has nothing to do with the healthy sport, but these people know what they are dealing with, and therefore it’s their decision.

  • Mrbrisvegas

    Fact 1.  Most women are much more attracted to wealth and status than to looks.

    Fact 2. Heterosexual women have a very strong preference to men who are a bit taller than average (6′-6’3) and relatively lean (BMI 23-25). This excludes all bodybuilders.

    My advice to any male who wants an attractive female partner is concentrate on becoming successful rather than pumping iron.

  • tod

    ever seen ronnies pot belly? its disgusting, any classical bodybuilder would laugh at it…..

  • tod

    70s and 80s bodybuilders like zane and arnold looked way better than todays mass monsters.